ClearBreach

← Guides·What is changing in Canadian privacy law →

Your SituationWe want our privacy basics in place →

PPCDAAll sectors

Bill C-36 (PPCDA): Canada's Proposed Privacy Law Would Let Customers Sue You Directly

By Yong DuPublished Reviewed

Share on LinkedIn

Bill C-36 would let individuals sue in any superior court once a contravention finding is final.

On this page

How enforcement worked under PIPEDA

Under PIPEDA, a person who believes an organization mishandled their personal information files a complaint with the Office of the Privacy Commissioner. The OPC investigates and can make recommendations; it cannot impose fines.

After receiving the OPC's report, the complainant can apply to the Federal Court for a hearing on certain matters, and the court can order the organization to comply and award damages (PIPEDA ss.14 and 16). The OPC can also apply itself. In practice, few complainants take that step, and Federal Court damages awards under PIPEDA have been modest.

The practical result: for most small organizations, a complaint finding has carried limited financial consequence.

What section 132 of the PPCDA changes

Once a contravention finding is final, affected individuals could sue the organization for damages in the Federal Court or a provincial superior court, as an ordinary civil action, not a review hearing tied to one complaint.

The organization would face two parallel exposures after a final finding:

  1. Administrative monetary penalties from the Commission, up to $10,000,000 or 3% of gross global revenue, whichever is greater (section 114 of the PPCDA)
  2. Civil damages claims from affected individuals (section 132)

Those two exposures are not mutually exclusive. Both can arise from the same finding.


The process under Bill C-36

Civil liability under section 132 requires a prior finding. The sequence is:

  1. Individual files a complaint with the Digital Safety and Data Protection Commission
  2. The Privacy and Consumer Data Commissioner investigates
  3. The Commission issues a finding, contravention confirmed or not
  4. If contravention confirmed: the individual can commence a civil action in Federal Court or a provincial superior court

Individuals cannot bypass the Commission and go directly to court. But once a finding confirming a contravention is issued, the door to civil litigation opens.


What this means for a small business

Under PIPEDA, privacy compliance has felt like a background regulatory risk, because the consequences of a complaint finding have been limited.

Bill C-36 would change that risk structure. A confirmed contravention finding opens the door to civil suits from every individual whose personal information was involved. A breach that affects 200 customers, a ransomware attack where client records were exposed, a phishing incident where an employee's email account gave access to a contact database, could, if a contravention is confirmed, expose the organization to civil claims from all 200 of them.

The individual damages claim for any one person may be modest. The cost of defending multiple actions, and the aggregate exposure, is not.


What makes a contravention finding more likely

Failure to notify when required. Section 58 of the PPCDA requires notification to the Commission and to affected individuals when a breach creates a real risk of significant harm. Failing to notify when the RROSH threshold was met is a clear contravention.

No documented RROSH assessment. If the organization cannot show that it assessed real risk of significant harm at the time of the breach (in writing, using the statutory factors) the argument that notification was not required is hard to sustain. The Commission will look for documentation made at the time, not a retrospective explanation filed after a complaint arrives.

No privacy management program. Section 9 of the PPCDA makes a documented program mandatory. An organization with no program is in contravention of section 9 independently of any breach. The Commission can find that contravention proactively, without waiting for an incident.

Sensitive categories of personal information. Health, financial, and identity information carry higher inherent risk. Breaches involving these categories are more likely to meet the RROSH threshold and more likely to produce demonstrable individual harm, which makes both the contravention finding and the subsequent damages claim more viable.


What lowers the exposure

The organizations with the lowest exposure under section 132 share one practice: they document their breach decisions at the time the decision is made.

That means:

  • Every breach is assessed for real risk of significant harm in writing, using the actual factors from section 58(8) of the PPCDA, at the time the breach is discovered
  • If the assessment concludes RROSH is present, notification happens and is documented
  • If the assessment concludes RROSH is not present, the reasoning is documented, not reconstructed after a complaint arrives
  • Breach records are maintained as required by section 60

This is not a sophisticated compliance program. It is a documented decision-making process applied consistently to every breach, regardless of how minor it appears at first. The organizations most exposed to section 132 liability are those that make informal breach decisions verbally, without documentation, and without applying the statutory factors.


Scope note

This article covers the PPCDA (Bill C-36), which would replace PIPEDA's private-sector rules and apply in the same way: to commercial activity across Canada, except activity within a province governed by a substantially similar provincial law. Quebec organizations primarily engaged in intra-provincial commercial activity are governed by Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (Law 25 / Bill 64), which has its own civil liability provisions. Quebec obligations are not covered here.


What to do now

The PPCDA is not yet law. PIPEDA remains operative. But the section 132 risk is reason to build the documentation practices now, because the breach decisions you make today will be the evidentiary record if a complaint is filed after the PPCDA comes into force.

Three practices that make the largest difference:

  1. Assess every breach for RROSH in writing, using the statutory factors. Not every breach requires notification. Every breach requires a documented assessment. That assessment is the primary protection against a finding that notification was required and withheld.

  2. Maintain breach records. Section 60 of the PPCDA requires it, and PIPEDA's equivalent requires it now. Every breach, every assessment, every notification decision belongs in the record.

  3. Build your privacy management program before the PPCDA comes into force. An organization with a documented, functional program is substantially harder to find in contravention under section 9. And a section 9 contravention is one of the bases that opens the door to section 132 civil actions.


Privacy case of the month

Once a month, a five-minute read: a real case a Canadian privacy commissioner investigated, what went wrong, and what to check in your own organization so it doesn't happen to you. Written for organizations under federal, Alberta and BC privacy law. Not written for Quebec.

We send one email to confirm. Nothing else arrives until you confirm, and an unconfirmed address is deleted after 7 days. Sent by ClearBreach Technologies Inc. Mailing address and contact details · Privacy policy


Start your breach assessment

The breach assessment process (documenting RROSH, deciding whether to notify, maintaining the breach record) is the most direct protection against a contravention finding under the PPCDA.

See a complete assessment →

A documented program reduces exposure to section 9 contraventions, which are what open the door to section 132 civil suits. The compliance assessment produces that documentation, and it is released with everything else at launch. Walk one on a fictional clinic →

Frequently asked questions

Could individuals sue organizations under PIPEDA?

Only through one narrow route. Under PIPEDA, an individual first complains to the OPC. After receiving the OPC's report, the complainant can apply to the Federal Court for a hearing on certain matters, and the court can order compliance and award damages (ss.14 and 16). The OPC cannot fine organizations. In practice, few complainants take that step.

How does the private right of action work under Bill C-36 and the PPCDA?

Section 132 of the PPCDA, as introduced, creates a right to sue for damages once a finding that the organization contravened the Act is final: for example, the Commissioner has made the finding and it was not reviewed or appealed in time, or a review or appeal confirmed it. The individual can then sue for damages in the Federal Court or a provincial superior court. The civil action requires a prior finding, individuals cannot bypass the Commission and go directly to court.

Does every data breach automatically give individuals the right to sue under the PPCDA?

No. The right to sue under section 132 is triggered by a confirmed contravention finding from the Commission, not by the breach itself. A breach that was properly assessed, properly notified where required, and properly documented may not result in a contravention finding at all. Civil liability under Bill C-36 attaches to contraventions of the PPCDA, not to breaches that were handled correctly.

What damages can individuals claim under the PPCDA private right of action?

Section 132 of the PPCDA authorizes a claim for damages following a confirmed contravention. The PPCDA does not prescribe fixed statutory damages, individuals must establish the harm they actually suffered as a result of the contravention. Breaches involving sensitive categories of personal information (health, financial, identity) typically produce more demonstrable harm and therefore more viable damages claims.

Does the Bill C-36 private right of action apply to Quebec organizations?

Quebec organizations primarily governed by Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (Law 25) have their own enforcement mechanisms under that Act. Like PIPEDA, the PPCDA would apply to activity that crosses a provincial or national border, so Quebec organizations can be subject to both regimes for different parts of their operations. Law 25 has its own civil liability provision, which is separate from section 132 of the PPCDA.

This guide is educational and does not constitute legal advice. It is grounded in the text of PIPEDA, Alberta PIPA, and BC PIPA and published guidance from the OPC, OIPC Alberta, and OIPC BC. If your situation involves regulatory investigation, litigation risk, or circumstances not addressed here, engage a qualified privacy lawyer.

See where you stand

Answer four questions about a fictional property manager and see where it stands in each area the law covers.

How ClearBreach shows what you have in place →

See plans and pricing →