← Guides·What is changing in Canadian privacy law →
Your SituationWe want our privacy basics in place →
Legitimate Interest Under Bill C-36 (PPCDA): New to Canadian Privacy Law
By Yong DuPublished Reviewed
Bill C-36's PPCDA introduces legitimate interest, a new basis to use personal information without consent that does not exist under PIPEDA.
On this page
What legitimate interest is
Legitimate interest is a legal basis for collecting, using, or disclosing personal information without consent from the individual.
It has existed in European privacy law, GDPR Article 6(1)(f), for years. Section 18(3) of Bill C-36's Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act introduces it to Canadian federal privacy law for the first time.
Under section 18(3) of the PPCDA, as introduced, an organization can collect, use or disclose personal information without consent only if three conditions are all met:
- Its legitimate interest in the activity outweighs any reasonably foreseeable adverse effect on the individual
- A reasonable person would expect the collection, use or disclosure for that activity
- The information is not collected, used or disclosed to influence the individual's behaviour or decisions
All three must be satisfied. Two out of three is not sufficient.
Why this matters for Canadian small businesses
PIPEDA operates primarily on consent, organizations need the individual's express or implied consent for most data uses. In practice, many low-risk business activities have been justified through implied consent, sometimes in ways that stretched the concept further than the OPC intended.
Bill C-36 would resolve some of that grey area by recognizing legitimate interest as a distinct exception. The documentation requirements are where most small businesses will find this more demanding than expected. Legitimate interest is not a replacement for consent or a way to avoid it. It is a different basis with its own obligations attached.
The three conditions
Condition 1: The interest outweighs the foreseeable adverse effects
The bill does not define "legitimate interest". European experience under GDPR Article 6(1)(f) suggests the kinds of activity likely to qualify:
- Fraud prevention and security monitoring
- Network and information security
- Internal audits and risk assessments
- Analytics that identify aggregate patterns without profiling individual people
This is a weighing exercise, not a declaration. Ask what harm an individual could experience, how likely it is, and how severe, and whether your interest still comes out ahead. Document the analysis; a bare assertion that "our interest outweighs the privacy impact" will not satisfy the Commission if challenged.
Condition 2: A reasonable person would expect it
The test is what a reasonable person would expect, not what your privacy policy says. Fraud checks on a payment are expected. Using a customer's purchase history for something unrelated to the service they bought is not.
Condition 3: Not used to influence behaviour or decisions
This condition is where the Canadian bill departs most from European practice. Direct marketing, which GDPR can allow under legitimate interest, is aimed at influencing what a person buys, so it falls outside section 18(3) as introduced. Marketing would still need consent.
The following are also unlikely to qualify:
- Selling personal information to data brokers, advertisers, or other third parties
- Building detailed profiles of individuals who have not interacted with the organization
- Collecting personal information for purposes unrelated to the service the individual requested
- Any processing the individual would clearly object to if told about it
The Digital Safety and Data Protection Commission, which the bill would create, will develop its own interpretation over time. Organizations that rely on this basis before guidance is published take on some interpretive risk.
The documentation requirements under sections 18(4)-(5) and 62
Before relying on legitimate interest under the PPCDA, the organization must (s.18(4)):
1. Conduct a Privacy Impact Assessment
The PIA must be done before the activity begins, not after the fact. It must identify the foreseeable adverse effects on individuals and the specific measures the organization will take to mitigate them. The organization must record the description of its interest, and give the Commission the description and the assessment on request (s.18(5)).
2. Identify and describe the legitimate interest in writing
Section 18(4)(a) requires the organization to identify and describe the interest, and s.18(5) requires that description to be recorded. A general statement will not do. "We rely on legitimate interest for fraud prevention" is not sufficient. The description should connect the specific activity to the specific interest.
3. Take reasonable measures to mitigate adverse effects
Where the PIA identifies risks, the organization must take concrete steps to reduce them. What constitutes "reasonable measures" depends on the sensitivity of the information and the nature of the activity.
4. Disclose publicly
Section 62(2)(b) of the PPCDA requires the organization's plain-language public information to include a description of any activities in which it relies on a legitimate interest.
This last requirement is the one most organizations do not anticipate. Relying on legitimate interest is not a private decision. It must appear in the organization's public privacy notice. Relying on legitimate interest without disclosing it publicly is not permitted under the PPCDA.
What changes under PIPEDA while waiting for the PPCDA
Legitimate interest does not exist as a legal basis under PIPEDA. While Bill C-36 is not yet in force, PIPEDA's consent framework applies. Organizations should not represent to individuals or regulators that they are relying on legitimate interest under current Canadian law.
What this period is useful for: identifying which of your current data uses rely on stretched implied consent, and assessing whether those uses would qualify under legitimate interest once the PPCDA comes into force. That analysis can be done now, before the obligation becomes enforceable.
Scope note
This article covers the PPCDA (Bill C-36), which would replace PIPEDA's private-sector rules and, like PIPEDA, apply to commercial activity across Canada except where a substantially similar provincial law governs activity within a province. Quebec organizations primarily engaged in intra-provincial commercial activity are governed by Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (Law 25 / Bill 64). Law 25 does not use the term "legitimate interest", its consent and exception framework is distinct from the PPCDA's. Quebec obligations are not covered here.
What to do before Bill C-36 comes into force
Four steps that prepare an organization for the legitimate interest obligation:
-
Inventory your current data uses. For each one, identify the legal basis you currently rely on, express consent, implied consent, legal obligation, or something else. Flag any that rely on implied consent for activities that feel like a stretch.
-
For each flagged use, assess whether it meets the legitimate interest test. Does the interest outweigh the possible harm? Would the individuals affected expect the use, or be surprised by it? Is any of it aimed at influencing their behaviour or decisions, such as marketing?
-
Draft written descriptions of the activities you expect to rely on legitimate interest for. Getting this language right before the obligation is enforceable is easier than writing it under time pressure after a complaint is filed.
-
Plan your PIA process for those activities. You do not need to complete formal PIAs now, the PPCDA is not in force. But identifying which activities will need PIAs and what information you will need to gather makes the process faster when the time comes.
Privacy case of the month
Once a month, a five-minute read: a real case a Canadian privacy commissioner investigated, what went wrong, and what to check in your own organization so it doesn't happen to you. Written for organizations under federal, Alberta and BC privacy law. Not written for Quebec.
We send one email to confirm. Nothing else arrives until you confirm, and an unconfirmed address is deleted after 7 days. Sent by ClearBreach Technologies Inc. Mailing address and contact details · Privacy policy
Related guides
- What Is Bill C-36? Canada's Proposed Privacy Law for Small Businesses
- What Is a Privacy Management Program Under Bill C-36 (PPCDA)?
- Bill C-36 (PPCDA): Canada's Proposed Privacy Law Would Let Customers Sue You Directly
Start your breach assessment
Breach reporting obligations under the PPCDA are identical to PIPEDA. Your current breach assessment process transfers directly. Confirm it is in place now.
The compliance assessment covers this. ClearBreach documents legitimate interest assessments and privacy impact assessments as part of the program review, which is released with everything else at launch. Walk one on a fictional clinic →
Frequently asked questions
What is legitimate interest under Bill C-36 and the PPCDA?
Legitimate interest is a legal basis that allows an organization to collect, use, or disclose personal information without obtaining consent from the individual. Section 18(3) of the PPCDA, as introduced, allows this only if three conditions are all met: the organization's legitimate interest outweighs any reasonably foreseeable adverse effect on the individual; a reasonable person would expect the collection, use or disclosure for that activity; and the information is not used to influence the individual's behaviour or decisions.
Is legitimate interest available under PIPEDA today?
No. PIPEDA does not contain a legitimate interest basis. Under PIPEDA, organizations must rely on consent, express or implied, for most data uses. Some organizations have stretched implied consent to cover activities that are better characterized as legitimate interests. Bill C-36's PPCDA introduces legitimate interest as a recognized basis, but it comes with documentation requirements that implied consent did not.
What is the difference between legitimate interest and implied consent under PIPEDA?
Implied consent under PIPEDA is inferred from context, the individual would reasonably expect their information to be used in a particular way. Legitimate interest under the PPCDA would be a formal exception with a defined three-part test, a mandatory Privacy Impact Assessment, a recorded description of the interest, and a public disclosure requirement. Legitimate interest provides more legal clarity than implied consent, but requires more documentation.
Does an organization need to conduct a Privacy Impact Assessment before relying on legitimate interest?
Yes. Section 18(4)(b) of the PPCDA requires the organization to conduct a Privacy Impact Assessment before relying on legitimate interest. The PIA must be done before the collection, use, or disclosure begins, not after the fact. It must identify any reasonably foreseeable adverse effect on individuals, and the organization must take reasonable measures to reduce or mitigate those effects. Legitimate interest cannot be claimed retroactively.
What happens if the Commission disagrees with our legitimate interest assessment under the PPCDA?
If the Commission investigates and concludes that the organization's reliance on legitimate interest was not justified, because the interest did not outweigh the adverse effects, a reasonable person would not have expected the use, or the information was used to influence behaviour, it may find a contravention of section 18(3). Under section 132 of the PPCDA, a confirmed contravention finding opens the door to civil suits from affected individuals. The written documentation of the interest and the PIA are the evidentiary record if the assessment is challenged.
This guide is educational and does not constitute legal advice. It is grounded in the text of PIPEDA, Alberta PIPA, and BC PIPA and published guidance from the OPC, OIPC Alberta, and OIPC BC. If your situation involves regulatory investigation, litigation risk, or circumstances not addressed here, engage a qualified privacy lawyer.
See where you stand
Answer four questions about a fictional property manager and see where it stands in each area the law covers.
How ClearBreach shows what you have in place →