On this page
Your SituationWe had a privacy incident →
In the middle of a breach?
ClearBreach shows whether you must report, to whom and by when, under each law that applies, and writes the reports.
Physical Records Breach, What Canadian Organizations Must Do
By Yong Du · Updated June 14, 2026
When paper records are lost or improperly destroyed, PIPEDA and PIPA treat it the same as a digital breach, notification obligations apply.
⚡ In an active breach right now?
Use the quick reference guide, built for use during an incident.
This playbook is educational and does not constitute legal advice. It is grounded in the text of PIPEDA, Alberta PIPA, and BC PIPA and published guidance from the OPC, OIPC Alberta, and OIPC BC. If your situation involves regulatory investigation, litigation risk, or circumstances not addressed here, engage a qualified privacy lawyer.
Lost, stolen or carelessly discarded paper is judged by the same test as a laptop. Work out what the files held and how long they were exposed, and treat every file that could have been reached as reached. A police report does not change your timeline: assess and, where the test is met, report as for any breach.
Which laws apply
| Jurisdiction | Applies when | Regulator |
|---|---|---|
| PIPEDA | The physical records contained personal information used in commercial activity; or the affected individuals are in provinces without substantially similar legislation (Ontario, Manitoba, New Brunswick, and others) | Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC), priv.gc.ca |
| Alberta PIPA | The breach involves your organization's activity in Alberta, including its employees there | OIPC Alberta, oipc.ab.ca / breachnotice@oipc.ab.ca |
| BC PIPA | The breach involves your organization's activity in BC, including its employees there | OIPC BC, oipc.bc.ca |
More than one of these can apply. If the threshold is met, report separately to the OPC and the OIPC Alberta where each applies; a report to the OIPC BC is voluntary.
What makes this scenario different
Every other breach scenario in these playbooks involves digital information, compromised credentials, exposed databases, misconfigured cloud storage. A physical records breach involves paper: files in a filing cabinet, boxes of records in transit, documents on a desk, paper recycling bins, or material handed to a third-party destruction service.
Three features distinguish this scenario.
The scope of what was accessed is often unknowable. In a digital breach, forensics can sometimes determine which files were opened, copied, or exfiltrated. In a physical breach, there is typically no way to know which specific pages a person read, copied, or took. If a filing cabinet is broken into, you know which files it contained, but not which ones were touched. If a box of records goes missing in transit, you know what should have been in the box, but not what condition the seal was in or whether anyone looked inside. Your RROSH assessment must account for the worst-case scope of what was accessible, not the optimistic case.
Improper destruction is a common and underappreciated cause. Many physical records breaches do not result from external theft. They come from failures inside the organization: unshredded client files in a hallway recycling bin, documents in the regular trash, a strip-cut shredder used on sensitive records, or a shredding service that issues certificates without destroying anything. These breaches are caused by the organization's own practices, which affects both the RROSH assessment and the remediation requirements.
The records may have been reachable for longer than the incident suggests. A filing cabinet left unlocked is not one moment of exposure. It is a window in which anyone who could get into the room could have looked. Determining the actual exposure window often requires reviewing access logs (if a building security system exists), interviewing staff, and reconstructing when the gap was created and when it was closed.
Immediate steps, this scenario specifically
1. Secure the remaining records immediately. If the breach involves a filing cabinet, records room, or physical space, ensure that space is secured and that no further unauthorized access is possible. Change locks if keys are missing. If documents are missing, determine what the filing cabinet or container held and produce a complete inventory.
2. Determine the scope of the physical breach. For a theft: what area was entered, what containers were accessed, what files were present? For lost records in transit: what was in the shipment, what carrier was used, and at what point did the records go missing? For improper destruction: what documents were affected, what destruction method was used, and when did it occur? For unauthorized viewing: who had access to the physical space, for what period, and what records were present?
3. Check whether a physical access record exists. Some organizations have building security systems, keycard logs, or CCTV that can narrow the exposure window or identify who entered the space. If these records exist, preserve them immediately, many systems overwrite footage after 30–72 hours.
4. Inventory the personal information that was in the affected records. List the categories of personal information in the lost, stolen, or improperly destroyed records: names, addresses, SINs, dates of birth, health information, financial records, signatures. Identify whose records they were (clients, employees, patients) and how many individuals are affected. This inventory is the foundation of your RROSH assessment.
5. Do not issue any public statement yet. Complete your RROSH assessment before communicating externally. If there was a theft, work with the police and record the report number. But the police investigation is separate from your duties to the regulator, which run on their own timeline.
What drives RROSH in this scenario
Factors that push toward RROSH:
- The records contained sensitive categories: health information, SINs, financial records (banking details, account numbers, credit card information), government-issued ID information, or information about minors
- The records contained enabling combinations: name + date of birth + address + SIN creates identity theft risk even if each field seems routine in isolation
- The breach involved deliberate theft, a targeted break-in is evidence of intent, not opportunistic access
- The records were accessible to an unknown number of people for an extended period (unlocked storage room, recycling bin in a common area)
- Improper destruction using a strip-cut shredder for sensitive documents, material can be reassembled
- Records were placed in regular trash and may have been accessed before pickup
- The destruction company has not provided a certificate of destruction or cannot confirm the records were destroyed
Factors that push against RROSH:
- The records contained only non-sensitive administrative information: appointment dates, general correspondence with no personal identifiers beyond name
- The records were in a locked container within a secured building and the breach involved no confirmed unauthorized access
- The loss was a single document with limited personal information and brief, incidental exposure
- The destruction was confirmed by a certified destruction service using a secure method with a certificate of destruction, and the incident was a procedural error that did not result in uncontrolled access
The scope-of-access problem: Physical breach RROSH assessments frequently must rely on worst-case scope because actual access cannot be determined. If a cabinet held 200 client files and someone unknown could reach it, treat all 200 as possibly seen. Do not try to estimate how many a person could have read in the time. Regulators do not expect certainty; they expect a conservative and honest assessment.
Likely verdict range
| Scenario | Typical verdict |
|---|---|
| Client or patient files containing health information, SINs, or financial data were stolen or are missing | RROSH, sensitive data with unknown access scope |
| Employee records including SINs, banking details, or compensation information were lost or stolen | RROSH, financial data combination |
| Documents containing SINs or financial records were placed in regular trash or recycled without shredding | RROSH, uncontrolled public access |
| Records were shredded using a strip-cut shredder | RROSH likely, material is reassemblable; treat as inadequate destruction |
| Client files containing name, address, and appointment history only were briefly left accessible | Case-by-case, depends on volume, duration of exposure, and who had access |
| A single non-sensitive document was briefly visible to one other person before being retrieved | Likely no reporting obligation, but document the incident |
| Records held by a certified destruction service were destroyed but no certificate was issued | Case-by-case, assess based on what the records contained and what confirmation exists |
Do your missing or exposed records need reporting? It turns on what they held and who could reach them. That is the decision ClearBreach makes, under PIPEDA, Alberta PIPA and BC PIPA at once. See it made on a real case →
Scenario-specific obligations and complications
If RROSH is determined:
- OPC notification (PIPEDA): Report to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada as soon as feasible after determining RROSH. Use the OPC breach report form at priv.gc.ca.
- OIPC Alberta notification (AB PIPA): Notify the OIPC Alberta without unreasonable delay. Email breachnotice@oipc.ab.ca. Use the official OIPC Alberta notification form.
- OIPC BC (BC PIPA): No legal duty to report; a voluntary report is encouraged for a significant breach in your BC activity.
- Individual notification: Notify each affected individual directly (required under PIPEDA; in Alberta when the commissioner directs, and best sent with the report; expected in BC). The notice should describe what happened, what type of records were involved, what information they contained, what steps the organization is taking, and what individuals can do to protect themselves. For a theft involving SINs or financial data, advise individuals to place a fraud alert with Equifax and TransUnion Canada and to monitor their accounts.
If RROSH is not determined:
- No regulator notification required under PIPEDA or Alberta PIPA.
- No individual notification required.
- Internal breach record, required under PIPEDA and good practice otherwise: document the physical incident, the records inventory, the RROSH assessment and reasoning, and any remediation steps taken.
- Review the physical safeguards that failed and document the corrective action.
BC PIPA, voluntary reporting option. BC PIPA has no breach reporting or notification duty, so any report to the OIPC BC is voluntary. For a significant breach in your BC activity, the BC Commissioner encourages a report and expects the people affected to be told where there is a risk of harm. See BC PIPA Breach Reporting.
For Ontario organizations. Ontario has no provincial private-sector privacy legislation, PIPEDA is the applicable framework. Report to the OPC at priv.gc.ca. No separate provincial regulator report is required. See Ontario Data Breach Reporting Requirements.
Complications specific to this scenario:
Records are missing but the cause is unknown, theft versus misplacement. An organization discovers a box of files is missing and cannot determine whether it was stolen, misplaced internally, or accidentally discarded. Treat this as a breach and conduct your RROSH assessment based on the worst-case scenario: that the records were accessed by an unauthorized person. Do not wait to resolve the internal uncertainty before assessing, if RROSH is present on the worst-case assumption, notify. Document your investigation into the cause and supplement your breach record as facts develop.
The police are investigating, can we wait for the investigation to conclude? No. Your PIPEDA and PIPA obligations are not suspended by a police investigation. A police report belongs in your breach record, and its number helps affected people place fraud alerts. But the investigation's timeline is not your reporting timeline. Assess RROSH on what you know and notify if the threshold is met. Update affected individuals if the investigation yields new information.
Records were mixed with general recycling or trash before the error was caught. If sensitive records went into recycling or trash and you got them back before collection, work out how long they sat there and who could reach them in that time. If collection already occurred, treat the records as having been accessible to an uncontrolled group (waste processing workers, people who encountered the bin before collection) and assess RROSH accordingly.
The records were in transit with a courier or shipping company. File a missing shipment claim with the carrier immediately and document the claim number. The carrier's investigation does not satisfy your RROSH assessment. Assess based on what the shipment contained and treat the records as potentially accessed by an unknown party. Your contract with the courier may give you a claim for damages. That contractual matter is separate from your regulatory obligations to affected individuals.
Third-party destruction service, records were not destroyed as contracted. If a document destruction company failed to destroy records, misplaced a shipment, or cannot provide a certificate of destruction, you remain the accountable organization. Contact the destruction company immediately in writing and request a full account of what happened. Assess RROSH based on what the records contained and the realistic likelihood of unauthorized access during the period they were outside your control. Document all correspondence with the destruction company.
Documents you will need
Regardless of RROSH determination:
- Internal breach record: date discovered, nature of the physical breach (theft, loss, improper destruction, unauthorized access), records inventory, number of individuals affected, RROSH assessment and outcome, remediation steps taken
- Police report number (if applicable)
- Certificate of destruction (if destruction company was involved and certificate was issued)
If RROSH is determined, also:
- OPC breach report (PIPEDA)
- OIPC Alberta breach notification (AB PIPA), if the breach involves your Alberta activity; email breachnotice@oipc.ab.ca
- OIPC BC voluntary report (BC PIPA), if the breach involves your BC activity and is significant
- Individual notification letters, one per affected individual or one per household
ClearBreach tells you which of these you need, and gives you the regulator reports and notification letters from your assessment answers.
Common mistakes in this scenario
Treating a physical breach as less serious than a digital breach. Regulators apply the same RROSH standard to paper records as to digital ones. A filing cabinet full of client SINs and health information that is stolen is not less serious than a database breach of the same information. The obligation to notify is identical.
Assuming the records were not accessed because they have not appeared elsewhere. The absence of evidence that stolen or lost records have been misused does not mean RROSH is absent. RROSH is assessed at the time of the breach based on the probability of harm, not after the fact based on whether harm has materialized. By the time harm is detectable, notification is already overdue.
Using a strip-cut shredder for sensitive records and treating it as secure destruction. Strip-cut shredders are not adequate for documents containing SINs, financial records, or health information. This is a common gap in small business physical records practices. If strip-cut shredding has been the standard practice for sensitive documents, a review of what has been processed through it and when is warranted.
No list of what records you hold. When a cabinet or box goes missing, organizations often cannot say quickly what was in it: whose records, what kind of information, how many people. Without a records inventory, the RROSH assessment is delayed and likely overstated. A basic inventory of what records are held, where they are stored, and how they are destroyed is both a privacy program requirement and a practical response tool.
Waiting for the police investigation before notifying regulators. Police investigations of document theft can take weeks or months, or may not result in charges. Your PIPEDA and PIPA notification timelines are not tied to the police investigation timeline. Assess and notify on your own schedule.
Not notifying after a shredding failure. Organizations sometimes find their shredding service did not destroy records, and decide not to notify because "they probably weren't seen." That is not the test. The test is whether there is a real risk of significant harm, given what the records held and what is known about where they went. If the destruction company cannot confirm what happened to the records, treat the worst case as the operative assumption.
Real-world example, physical records breach
Client files belonging to an Alberta law firm were stolen from an employee's car. They held driver's licence copies, cheques and mortgage documents for 10 clients.
OIPC Alberta found a real risk of significant harm and required the clients to be notified. Paper files are judged by the same test as a laptop: a stolen file containing a client's identity documents and financial details is assessed exactly as a digital breach of the same data would be.
The lesson is about transit. A vehicle, even a locked one, is not a secure place to keep personal information, so limit which original documents leave the office and how they travel.
Source: OIPC Alberta, Decision P2022-ND-026, Breach notification decisions
MSP note
If you manage IT infrastructure for clients but this incident involves physical records at a client's location:
A paper breach is outside an MSP's technical work. You may still be involved if the papers included passwords, printed access details or copies of data your systems hold. If the lost papers put the client's systems at risk too, through printed passwords, access cards or network diagrams, assess that as a second breach at the same time, using the right digital playbook as well as this one.
If you operate a physical document management or destruction service for clients, a breach of records in your custody makes you the vendor in this scenario. Your obligations run in two directions: your own regulatory notification as an organization that experienced a breach, and your contractual obligation to notify affected clients immediately.
Ready to assess this breach? Find out whether you must report it, to whom and by when, under each law that applies, with the regulator reports and notification letters to send. See it done on a worked case →
The demonstration is the real assessment, already answered for a fictional company, with three answers left for you to change. It ends on the verdict and the documents it produced. See a real verdict → to run it on your own breach.
This playbook covers PIPEDA, Alberta PIPA, and BC PIPA obligations for private-sector organizations. If your organization handles personal health information under provincial health legislation, such as Alberta's Health Information Act or BC's E-Health (Personal Health Information Access and Protection of Privacy) Act, additional obligations may apply when physical health records are lost, stolen, or improperly destroyed. Those obligations are not covered here.
Related guides
- How Canadian Regulators Decide Whether a Breach Must Be Reported. More real regulator decisions, across every type of breach
- PIPEDA Breach Reporting Requirements, when and how to notify the OPC under PIPEDA
- Alberta PIPA Breach Notification, AB PIPA notification obligations and OIPC process
- BC PIPA Breach Reporting, what BC PIPA does and does not require after a breach, and the OIPC BC process
- What Is RROSH?, the real risk of significant harm standard explained
- Physical Records Breach, Quick Reference, checklist for use during the incident
Frequently asked questions
Paper files were stolen from our office, is this a reportable breach?
It depends on what the files contained and whether RROSH, real risk of significant harm, is present. PIPEDA and PIPA apply equally to paper records and digital records. A theft of physical files is a breach of security safeguards. Your RROSH assessment turns on the sensitivity of the information in the files, whose information it was, and what harm could realistically result from a third party possessing those documents. Files containing SINs, financial records, health information, or identity-enabling combinations will almost always meet the RROSH threshold.
We shredded documents but used a standard office shredder, is that secure destruction?
It depends on the shredder's cut level. Strip-cut shredders (long ribbons of paper) do not meet the standard for secure destruction of sensitive personal information, documents shredded in strips can be reassembled. Cross-cut and micro-cut shredders are considered secure for most personal information. If documents containing SINs, health records, or financial data were processed through a strip-cut shredder, treat this as a potential breach and conduct a RROSH assessment.
A client file was left on a desk and visible to other clients in our waiting room, do we have to report this?
Usually not, if the exposure was brief and limited. Incidental viewing of a file name or a client's name on a folder typically does not constitute a breach of security safeguards sufficient to trigger RROSH. However, if the file was open and contained sensitive information (health details, financial data, personal identification) and was clearly visible to multiple individuals for a meaningful period, conduct a RROSH assessment. Document the incident regardless of your RROSH determination, the internal documentation obligation applies to all security incidents.
We use a third-party document destruction company, are we still responsible if they mishandle the records?
Yes. Under PIPEDA clause 4.1.3, Alberta PIPA s.5(2) and BC PIPA s.4(2), you remain the accountable organization for personal information you transfer to a third party for destruction, the same as for any other processing. A contract with a destruction company that includes a certificate of destruction is a due-diligence measure, it does not transfer your statutory accountability to the individuals whose information it was. If the destruction company mishandles the records and RROSH results, your notification obligations apply regardless of what your contract with them says.
Ready to assess this breach?
See whether you must report, to whom and by when, under each privacy law that applies to you, with the reports and letters to show for it.
How ClearBreach handles a breach →Privacy case of the month
Once a month, a five-minute read: a real case a Canadian privacy commissioner investigated, what went wrong, and what to check in your own organization so it doesn't happen to you. Written for organizations under federal, Alberta and BC privacy law. Not written for Quebec.
We send one email to confirm. Nothing else arrives until you confirm, and an unconfirmed address is deleted after 7 days. Sent by ClearBreach Technologies Inc. Mailing address and contact details · Privacy policy